Devonalds Solicitors Banner Image

Devonalds Blog

Services
People
News and Events
Other
Blogs

Mesher Orders: What Happens to the Family Home in a Divorce?

Reviewed by:
View profile for Jodie Davies
Jodie Davies, Associate Partner

Last updated :

When you’re going through a divorce with children, the family home is often the first thing on your mind. Can one of you stay in it with the children, or does it have to be sold? If a solicitor or the court has mentioned a Mesher order, this guide explains what it is, how it works, and what your realistic options are.

What happens to the family home when you divorce?

There’s no automatic rule, no presumption that the mother keeps the house, and no default 50/50 split. The family court in England and Wales considers every case on its own facts.

In practice, there are three realistic outcomes: the home is sold and the net proceeds divided, one of you buys the other out, or the sale is deferred so that one of you and the children can stay put.

The court’s first consideration, under section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, is the welfare of any child under 18. After that, it looks at whether both parties’ housing needs can be met from what’s available. Our guide to how assets are split in a divorce covers the wider settlement; this article focuses on the deferred sale.

What is a Mesher order?

A Mesher order is a court order that requires the family home to be sold, but postpones the sale until a defined future event. In the meantime, one party (usually the parent the children live with) has the right to stay in the property. Both parties hold a share of the property, typically in fixed proportions, for example 60% and 40%.

The name comes from the 1980 Court of Appeal decision in Mesher v Mesher. It isn’t a separate statutory category; it’s a form of order for sale made under section 24A of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, and it must always be incorporated into a financial order approved by the court.

How a Mesher order works: deferred sale and trigger events

A Mesher order fixes three things from the outset: the shares each party will receive when the property is sold, who has the right to live there until then, and exactly what will bring the arrangement to an end.

The events that end the occupation and trigger the sale are called trigger events. Those appearing in most orders include:

  • The youngest child reaching 18 or finishing full-time secondary education
  • The occupying party remarrying or cohabiting with a new partner for a defined period, often six months
  • The occupying party’s death
  • The occupying party voluntarily moving out or agreeing to a sale
  • A further order of the court

These trigger events are negotiable, but vague drafting is the single biggest source of later disputes. “Finishing education” needs precise definition: does it include a gap year, a return to study, or postgraduate courses? Getting the wording right at the outset matters.

When will a court make a Mesher order?

Mesher orders are used far less often than clients expect, and courts approach them cautiously. They’re most likely where there are dependent children, where an immediate sale would leave them without suitable housing, and where there’s enough equity that the non-occupying party can realistically rehouse when the sale eventually happens.

They’re least likely where the equity is small, where the delay would leave the non-occupying party unable to rehouse at all, or where the parties are unlikely to cooperate over the property for years.

The court also has a duty under section 25A of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 to consider whether a clean break is achievable. A Mesher order keeps both parties financially tied for years, which runs counter to that principle.

Mesher orders vs Martin orders: the difference

A Mesher order and a Martin order both defer the sale of the family home, but they serve different purposes.

Mesher order

  • Sale deferred until…
  • Youngest child reaches 18 or finishes education, plus other triggers
  • Typical circumstances
  • Dependent children; both parties can eventually rehouse
  • Effective duration
  • Until the youngest child is an adult

Martin order

  • Sale deferred until…
  • Death, remarriage or cohabitation of the occupying party
  • Typical circumstances
  • No dependent children; occupying party unable to rehouse on their share
  • Effective duration
  • Potentially for the occupying party’s lifetime

A Martin order tends to arise in longer marriages where there are no dependent children, but one party could not afford suitable housing on their share of the proceeds alone.

The drawbacks of a Mesher order

A Mesher order can feel like the obvious answer, but it carries real disadvantages:

  • No clean break. Both parties remain financially tied to the property, sometimes for many years, affecting borrowing capacity and future financial planning.
  • Locked capital. The non-occupying party can’t access their share until the trigger event. By the time the property sells, they may be older and find that mortgage lending is harder to access.
  • Ongoing disputes. Who pays for repairs? Does a major improvement by the occupying party affect the shares? The order doesn’t always answer these questions.
  • Market risk. The sale happens at a point neither party controls.

Can I refuse a Mesher order?

Once a court has made an order, you can’t refuse to comply with it: it’s binding. However, you can oppose one being made in the first place.

In practice, most financial settlements are agreed rather than imposed by a judge. The realistic route is negotiation: through correspondence, at the Financial Dispute Resolution (FDR) appointment, or at a final hearing. Your solicitor can help you set out why a deferred sale wouldn’t work and put alternatives on the table.

If an order has already been made and circumstances change significantly, you can apply to vary it, but the grounds are limited.

Alternatives to a Mesher order

The options your solicitor should explore with you include:

  • Immediate sale. The property is sold now and the net proceeds are divided, giving both parties certainty and capital to rehouse.
  • Buy-out. One party transfers their interest to the other, who takes over the mortgage (with the lender’s consent).
  • Deferred charge. The departing party takes a defined percentage of the net proceeds whenever the property eventually sells, without the rigid trigger structure of a Mesher order.
  • Offsetting. One party keeps a larger share of the house; the other keeps more of the pension or other assets. Pension capital and housing capital aren’t equivalent, though, so this is rarely a straightforward swap. [LINK: Pension Sharing on Divorce blog - in production] sets out what to consider.

Can I be forced to sell my house in a divorce?

Yes. The family court has power under section 24A of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 to order the sale of the family home where that’s the only way to meet both parties’ needs fairly.

For unmarried couples, the position is different. There’s no financial claim under the Matrimonial Causes Act, so the route is a claim under the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996 (TOLATA), or under Schedule 1 of the Children Act 1989 where there are children. A Mesher-style outcome is possible but reached by a different legal route. The gov.uk guidance on money and property when you separate gives a useful overview.

What happens to the mortgage under a Mesher order?

A financial court order is binding between you and your former spouse, but it doesn’t bind your mortgage lender.

If the mortgage is in joint names, it stays in joint names until the property is sold or the lender agrees to release one party. Both of you remain liable to the lender for the full debt, whatever the court order says between you. Missed payments affect both credit records.

The order will usually set out who pays the monthly mortgage payments, typically the occupying party. Those payments are sometimes treated as a form of occupation rent or reflected in the eventual shares. Where a house is in negative equity (the outstanding mortgage exceeds what the property is worth), a Mesher order isn’t usually viable.

How Devonalds Solicitors can help

Our family law solicitors can advise on whether a deferred sale is realistic in your circumstances, negotiate and draft trigger events precisely to avoid later disputes, deal with mortgage lenders and transfers of equity, and incorporate the final agreement into a financial consent order [LINK: Financial Consent Order blog - in production] that’s binding on both of you.

We work from offices across South Wales in Bridgend, Pontypridd, Caerphilly, Church Village, Tylorstown, Tonypandy, Talbot Green and Treorchy. Visit our family law pricing page for details of our fees, or get in touch for an initial discussion. If you’re at the very start of the process, our guide to getting a divorce: first steps to take is a good place to begin.

Frequently asked questions

Does the mother automatically get the house in a divorce?

No. There is no rule that favours mothers. The court’s first consideration is the welfare of any child under 18. The parent the children live with most of the time often has the stronger housing need, but that’s a consequence of the children’s welfare, not the parent’s gender.

Is a Mesher order the same as a clean break?

No, it is different. A clean break order severs all financial ties between you completely, straightaway. A Mesher order keeps both parties financially bound to the property for years. The court must consider whether a clean break is achievable before making a Mesher order.

Can I force the sale of my house in a divorce?

No, you cannot insist on selling a house in divorce but you can negotiate to try to achieve this. Otherwise, the court will make the order it considers to be fair and reasonable in the circumstances.

How much does it cost to get a financial order?

A modest court fee for a financial consent order (where you’ve agreed the terms) is payable, with a contested application costing more. The current fee is listed in the gov.uk court fees guidance. For our solicitor fees, see our family law pricing page.

What happens if my ex refuses to leave the family home?

Occupation during separation is a separate issue from the financial settlement. Until a court order is made, both parties normally have the right to occupy the family home. Where there is domestic abuse or an urgent need for protection, an occupation order under the Family Law Act 1996 may be available. Our injunctions and occupation orders page explains the options.

Can I be made to sell my house if we were never married?

If you weren’t married, there’s no financial claim under the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, meaning a Mesher order for unmarried couples is not an option. Disputes are usually resolved through a claim under TOLATA, which focuses on beneficial ownership rather than needs, or through Schedule 1 of the Children Act 1989 where there are children. The MoneyHelper guidance on sorting out money when you separate is a useful starting point.